Table 7.4 Effectiveness of Pragmatic and Emotional Intelligence Interventions
| Author/ Year/
Country/ Study Design/ N |
Methods | Outcomes |
| Westerhof-Evers et al. (2017)
Netherlands RCT PEDro=7 NInitial=61, NFinal=56 |
Population: TBI; Mean Age=43.2 yr; Gender: Male=83, Female=17; Severity: Moderate to severe.
Treatment: Participants were randomly assigned to receive Treatment for Impairments in Social Cognition and Emotion Regulation (T-ScEmo, n=30) protocol or Cogniplus (n=29) training. The TScEmo protocol is aimed at enhancing emotion perception, perspective taking, theory of mind, goal-directed social behaviour through 20 individual treatment sessions offered 1-2x/wk by neuropsychologists. Cogniplus is an individually administered computerized attention training aimed at improving general cognition. Outcomes were assessed baseline (T0), post-intervention (T1), and 3-5 mo follow-up (T2). Outcome Measure: The Awareness of Social Inferences Test (TASIT-short), Sixty faces test (FEEST), Cartoon test, Faux Pas test (FP), Wechsler Adult Intelligence Scale (WAIS-III digit span), Trail Making Test (TMT A and B/A), Test of Everyday Attention Lottery (TEA lottery), Dysexecutive Questionnaire-Social scales (DEX-Soc-self, DEX-Soc-proxy), Brock’s Adaptive Functioning Questionnaire-Social monitoring scale (BAFQ-SM-self, BAFQ-SM-proxy), BAFQ empathy scale (BAFQ-Emp-self, BAFQ-Emp-proxy), Role Resumption List (RRL), Quality of Life after Brain Injury (QOLIBRI satisfaction, QOLIBRI burden), Treatment Goal Attainment (TGA), Relationship Quality Scale (RQS-self, RQS-life partner). |
|
| Neumann et al. (2015)
USA RCT PEDro=9 NInitial=71, NFinal=60 |
Population: TBI; Faces (n=24): Mean Age=41 yr; Gender: Male=23, Female=1; Mean Time Post Injury=10.5yr; Mean GCS=6.9; Stories (n=23): Mean Age=41.5 yr; Gender: Male=18, Female=5; Mean Time Post Injury=10.9 yr; Mean GCS=4.4; Control (n=24): Mean Age=39.5 yr; Gender: Male=16, Female=8; Mean Time Post Injury=9.8yr; Mean GCS=5.3.
Treatment: Participants randomly assigned to one of three interventions for 1 hr sessions 3 days/wk for 3 wk. Faces intervention taught individuals to recognize emotions in facial expressions, whereas stories intervention taught individuals to recognize emotion within stories. Control group underwent cognitive training. Participants assessed at pre-treatment and post-treatment within 4 days, at 3 mo and 6 mo. Outcome Measure: Diagnostic Assessment of Nonverbal Accuracy 2-Adult Faces (DANVA 2-AF), Emotional Inference From Stories Test (EIST), Interpersonal Reactivity Index (IRI), Neuropsychiatric Inventory (NPI) Irritability and Aggression domain. |
|
| McDonald et al. (2013)
Australia RCT PEDro=6 N=20 |
Population: Severe TBI=16, CVA=3, Other=1; Mean Age=45.62 yr; Gender: Male=15, Female=5; Mean Time Post Injury=9.41 yr. Treatment: Patients were assigned to either a treatment group (n=10) or a control group (n=10). Patients receiving treatment attended 2hr/wk treatment sessions for 3 wk. Sessions consisted of a therapist and two participants. The program was tailored to focus on prosodic cues that may be seen in expressions of emotions. Outcome Measure: Awareness of Social Interference Test Form B-Part 1 (audio presentation), Prosodic Emotion Labelling Task, Communication Questionnaires. |
|
| Radice-Neumann et al. (2009) USA RCT PEDro=5 Nintial=21, Nfinal=19 |
Population: TBI=19, ABI=2; Mean Age=43 yr; Gender: Male=12, Female=8; Mean Time Post Injury=12 yr; Mean GCS=4.08.
Treatment: Patients were randomly assigned to receive either the facial affect recognition (FAR; n=10) training or the stories of emotional inference training (SEI; n=9). In the FAR training, individuals practiced identifying and discriminating emotions from facial expressions and focused on processing their internal emotions. SEI involved reading stories and answering questions. Sessions were 1:1 for 1 hr, 3 x/wk for 2-3 wk. |
|
| Gabbatore et al. (2015)
Italy Pre-Post NInitial=20, NFinal=15 |
Population: TBI; Mean Age=36.7 yr; Gender: Male=10, Female=5; Mean Time Post Injury=76.13 mo; Mean GSC=4.5.
Treatment: Participants received a control procedure with non-communication activities for 3 mo. This was followed by a 3 mo cognitive pragmatic training program (2 sessions/wk) consisting of 5-patient groups focussed on improving pragmatic abilities, self awareness, and executive function. Outcome Measure: Assessment Battery for Communication (ABaCo-comprehension, production, linguistic, extralinguistic, paralinguistic, and context), Attentive Matrices, Trail Making test, Verbal Span, Spatial Span, Immediate and Deferred Recall test, Tower of London test, Wisconsin Card Sorting test (WCST), Coloured Progressive Matrices Raven, Aachener Aphasie test-denomination scale (AAT), Sally and Ann Task, Strange Stories Task. |
|
PEDro = Physiotherapy Evidence Database rating scale score (Moseley et al., 2002).